Marco Island, the small but mighty gem off the shores of Southwestern Florida, is known for more than just its beautiful beaches. The island, measuring just 12 square miles in size, is home to an impressive selection of restaurants to please any palate. From casual beachfront eateries to upscale Italian dining, Marco Island has it all.
We’ve gathered up this guide to the best restaurants on the island, to help you find the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings. Whether you’re looking for an inexpensive breakfast or lunch spot, or a fine-dining experience, you’ll find something to please your taste buds here.
# Inexpensive Restaurants on Marco Island
Joey's Marco Island Pizzeria Restaurant And Bar
Doreen’s Cup of Joe is the ideal spot for breakfast and lunch. Whether you’re in the mood for something sweet – like crunchy French toast, house-made donut holes with fresh berries, or lemon ricotta pancakes – or something savory – like a Californian omelet, huevos rancheros, or a biscuit sandwich – you’ll find it here. Plus, you can enjoy your meal with a cappuccino, freshly-squeezed orange juice, mimosa, sweet tea, or coffee cocktail. Doreen’s also serves classic lunch fare, such as burgers, sandwiches, and salads.
Sunset Grille is the perfect spot for a casual seafood meal. Enjoy a tasty lunch or dinner under the thatched roof bar, with dishes like the fish & chips basket, snow crab legs, grilled teriyaki salmon, or their famous crab cake sandwich. Don’t forget to order one of their signature cocktails – like the sunset grille mai tai, tropical tea, or a day at the beach.
The Speakeasy is a unique spot that offers classic comfort food with a twist. Enjoy dishes like hogfish snapper, the prohibition burger, chicken piccata, or the loaded Chicago-style Italian beef pizza. Don’t forget to order one of their signature cocktails – after all, it was named after the Prohibition Era!
# Moderately-priced Restaurants on Marco Island
Stonewalls is a family-owned restaurant that serves up breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Start your day with a crab cake benny, French toast, or breakfast burrito. For lunch, try the Philly cheesesteak, Chicago dog, or meatball parm sandwich. For dinner, indulge in comfort food like homemade meatloaf, hearty chicken soup, or the chicken pot pie.
Snook Inn is a casual waterfront favorite offering scrumptious seafood platters. Try dishes like seafood chowder, crispy calamari, Caribbean mahi mahi, or the restaurant’s famous grouper sandwich. Wash it down with a tropical cocktail like a mai tai, tiki rum punch, raspberry mojito, or the original rum runner.
Mango’s Dockside Bistro is a kitschy spot with a nautical atmosphere, a 750-gallon fish tank, and a cascading waterfall. Try conch fritters with tasty sauces for dipping, fish tacos, macadamia nut crusted cobia, or the house specialty, the whiskey burger. And check out their sushi menu for some of the freshest seafood around.
# Fine Dining on Marco Island
Sale E Pepe is the perfect spot for Italian dining. With a focus on Southern Italian fare, the menu features lots of tomatoes and seafood. Try the spaghetti allo scoglio (with seafood), the risotto al fiore e gamberi (risotto with squash flowers and shrimp), and pair it with one of their fabulous wines.
Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant is a great spot for surf and turf. Enjoy delicacies like creamy Maine bisque, Wagyu beef carpaccio, braised short ribs, Chilean sea bass, and petite filet mignon, all perfectly prepared with love. Don’t forget to save room for the chocolate souffle – it’s so fresh that you should order it with your entrees, as it takes 30 minutes to prepare.
Davinci Ristorante Italiano is an upscale eatery that feels straight out of Italy. The family that owns this popular restaurant immigrated to the U.S. from Mesoraca and brought their family recipes with them. Try classics like tortelloni di carne, Porcini Pizza, and pair it with a nice red from their extensive wine menu.
No matter how you slice it, a visit to any (or all!) of these wonderful Marco Island restaurants will be sure to satisfy your cravings.
Looking for a vacation rental on Marco Island?
Here's a sneak peak of our properties: